Mexico Forest Protocol Version 1.0
|Mexico Forest Protocol Version 1.0 (October 23, 2013)||The protocol was approved by the Reserve Board on October 23, 2013 to undergo a pilot project phase.|
|Protocolo Forestal para México Versión 1.0 (Octubre 23, 2013)|
The Climate Action Reserve developed the Mexico Forest Protocol for over three years with a diverse set of stakeholders, including government agencies, nonprofit organizations, private sector, and landowners, both in the United States and in Mexico. See below for detailed information on protocol development, including public comment submissions, public workshops, workgroup meetings, a list of workgroup participants, and other resources.
Revised Version 1.0 Public Comments
The protocol underwent a second public comment period in August 2013 to solicit feedback on the revised draft of the protocol; see below for the staff response to the one comment received. The second comment period did not result in any changes to the protocol.
The Reserve hosted a public webinar on Wednesday, September 4, 2013 to present details on the revised draft of the protocol and provide a venue for public comments. Workshop materials are available below.
Version 1.0 Public Comments
The protocol underwent an initial public comment period in January 2011 and the Reserve responded to comments (see below) and made substantial modifications to the protocol based on stakeholder feedback. Some of the important changes from the first draft include:
- Guidance for crediting avoided emissions has been removed from the current draft. This is consistent with the evolution of thinking in Mexico associated with REDD+ activities.
- Communal lands and private ownerships are eligible to develop projects.
- The approach to baseline enables varied sequestration activities to be credited under one project, including improved forest management, reforestation, and agroforestry.
- Environmental and social safeguards have been added directly into the protocol. Rather than relying on third-party criteria to define safeguards, the Reserve will require, monitor, and verify a set of safeguards that have been vetted by stakeholders.
- The approach to permanence has been modified to account for the temporal value of the project activity.
The Reserve has assembled a workgroup to assist with the development of the adaptation of the Reforestation, Avoided Deforestation, and Sustainable Forest Management project types. The workgroup includes:
|Alianza para la Conservación Sierra Gorda||M-REDD|
|Baker & McKenzie||Pronatura Mexico|
|Border Environment Cooperation Commission (BECC/COCEF)||Pronatura Sur|
|Centro Mexicano de Derecho Ambiental||Rainforest Alliance|
|CONAFOR||Servicios Ambientales de Oaxaca|
|Consejo Civil Mexicano para la Silvicultura Sostenible||South Pole Carbon Asset Management|
|EcoLogic Development Fund||Terra Global Capital|
|Environmental Defense Fund (EDF)||The Nature Conservancy|
|Gold Standard||Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (UNAM)|
|GHG Offset Services||Verified Carbon Standard (VCS)|
|Governors’ Climate and Forests Taskforce (GCF)||World Wildlife Fund|
- The Mexico Forest Protocol Workgroup is seeking to address environmental and social safeguards through an existing standard. The current thinking in the workgroup is that a project would need to be certified through a third-party standard in order to participate in a Climate Action Reserve forest carbon project. In order to evaluate the existing standards, the principles addressed in each standard were documented and assessed as to whether objective criteria and indicators are provided in the standard to ensure that verification of the principle would be consistently applied. The assessment of the existing standards will also consider the expected explicit requirements of the compliance market in California related to environmental and social integrity. The standards reviewed include:
- - Climate, Community, and Biodiversity (Project and Jurisdiction)
- Plan Vivo
- The Gold Standard
- Forest Stewardship Council
- REDD+ Amazon Standards (Brazil)
The discussion is ongoing as the workgroup considers which principles are most important to align with Mexico’s REDD+ Vision and with California’s cap and trade regulation.
- Environmental Safeguards Comparison Matrix
- Environmental Safeguards – FSC Standard
- Environmental Safeguards – Gold Standard
- Environmental Safeguards – REDD+ Standard
- Environmental Safeguards – REDD + Brazilian Amazon Standards
- Environmental Safeguards – Plan Vivo Standards
- Envornmental Safeguards – CC&B Standards
- Social Safeguards Comparison Matrix
- Social Safeguards – FSC Standard
- Social Safeguards- Gold Standard
- Social Safeguards – REDD+ Standard
- Social Safeguards – REDD+ Brazilian Amazon Standards
- Social Safeguards – Plan Vivo Standards
- Social Safeguards – CC&B Standards
To ensure that the protocol development process is transparent and open, the Reserve makes available to the general public documentation from the workgroup portion of protocol development as it occurs. Click here to view meeting notes and other resources from all past workgroup meetings. For added transparency, interested individuals may also participate in workgroup calls/webinars as an “observer.” Please note that observers will be in listen only mode during calls/webinars.
If you are interested in reviewing the existing US Forest Project Protocol or the US Project Implementation Agreement (PIA) both documents are available in Spanish and English.
- U.S. Forest Project Protocol Version 3.1 (October 22, 2009)
- Protocolo de Proyectos Forestales Version 3.1 (October 22, 2009)
- US Project Implementation Agreement – Espanol
- US Project Implementation Agreement – English
- Mexico Forest Project Protocol Statement of Intent (March 4, 2010)
- Declaracion de Intenciones (March 4, 2010)
If you have questions about the Mexico Forest Protocol, please contact:
John Nickerson at firstname.lastname@example.org
The Reserve at [English] 213-891-1444, Press 3, or email@example.com
The Reserve at [Espanol] 213-891-1444, Oprima 6, o firstname.lastname@example.org